A few weeks ago, I prepared a workshop on the ethical use of artificial intelligence in education. Using AI, I designed a practice game for fourth-grade pupils. The result arrived in seconds: colourful, well organised, with clear instructions. It looked finished.
But when I reviewed it with pedagogical judgement, I found more than ten real errors: a question that contained the answer in its own wording, vocabulary beyond the level of the curriculum, English audio read with Spanish phonetics. An eight-year-old would not have learnt anything useful. They would have played, yes. Learnt with judgement, no.
That is exactly what I mean when I say that all that glitters is not gold. And I ask myself: what example are we setting for those who come after us?
AI in Education: A Tool, Not a Guru
Artificial intelligence can be very useful. I can ask it for the capital of France, ask it to explain photosynthesis, to suggest ideas for a lesson, to help me structure a text. For that, it works well. The problem is not the tool itself: the problem is when we ask more of it than it can give, or when we use it without the judgement that only a human being can bring.
In the classroom, only a teacher with pedagogical training can spot that an AI-generated activity has errors of level, validity or pronunciation. AI does not know your pupils. It does not know who arrived in tears today, who has learning difficulties or what is going on at home. The teacher knows that. And that difference is no minor detail: it is the heart of education.
AI and Mental Health: A Line That Must Not Be Crossed
In August 2025, a young woman going through a serious crisis was confiding her darkest thoughts to a chatbot rather than to the people who could help her.
Artificial intelligence can help me prepare a lesson. It cannot replace the psychologist, the counsellor, the teacher who sees in a pupil’s eyes that something is wrong. Questions of mental health, identity, family and pain demand human presence. They demand a human heart. No algorithm will hold a pupil in crisis.
That line is not negotiable.
Ethical Use of AI in the Classroom: The Responsibility Is Ours
Decisions about how, when and why we use AI in the classroom are made by us, the adults. Not by pupils, not by platforms, not by technology companies. By us. And that means knowing which tools are appropriate for our pupils’ age because, for example, most primary school children are under the minimum age of 13 required by the best-known AI platforms. It means knowing what data is exposed, for what purpose, and who checks what the machine produces before it reaches a child.
In my experience, working in education is far from easy. The decisions we make affect real lives. That is why judgement cannot be delegated to an algorithm. Every decision about the use of AI in education must help pupils to be well, even when it is not fun, popular or the easiest option.
The seed we sow today with technology will be the judgement our pupils have tomorrow. That is legacy.
Magnifica humanitas and Marie Eugenie: Safeguarding What Is Human
I was educated at La Asunción in Guayaquil in a philosophy that Mother Marie Eugenie summed up in a phrase I have never forgotten: “It is folly not to be what one is as fully as possible” (Milleret, M.E. (1844) Letter to d’Alzon). In education, this means teaching with everything we are: judgement, heart, presence. Not handing that over to any machine.
In May 2026, Pope Leo XIV presented the encyclical Magnifica humanitas with a statement that resonated deeply with me:
“…lovingly safeguard the grandeur of humanity bestowed upon us and revealed in its fullness in Christ, the splendour of which no machine can ever replace”.
It is not a rejection of technology. It is a call not to surrender to it. To safeguard who we are. To remember that what makes an educator great is not the tool they use, but the humanity with which they teach.
The Real Gold: A Teacher with a Vocation
AI can shine brightly. It can generate materials in seconds, suggest paths and save us time. But in education, what transforms is the teacher who enters the classroom with a sense of vocation, who notices when a pupil is doing well or badly, who supports, who accompanies, who does not give up on the learning process. No algorithm does that.
Mother Marie Eugenie also taught us that “everything comes from Jesus Christ, everything belongs to Jesus Christ, everything must be for Jesus Christ” (Milleret, M.E. (1884) Chapter Instruction). And that means that knowledge, even technological knowledge, only makes sense if it is at the service of others. I keep training in AI in education precisely because I believe in its value. But that same training confirms to me that a powerful tool without ethics, without limits and without a sense of service ceases to be a tool and becomes a risk.
Let us use AI with judgement, with clear limits and with adult responsibility. And let us always remember that on the other side of every screen there is a human being in formation, who deserves the best of us, not the fastest a machine can offer.
What seed are we sowing?
Albania Cadena Aguilar
Guayaquil, Ecuador